A Petty Complaint
Okay. I’ve been in classrooms, both as a student and as a teacher, where cell phones have embarrassed everyone by bursting into their cheerful, abrasive songs. And really, it has been an embarrassment: both my classmates and my students had the grace to be utterly abashed and swear not to let it happen again. These interruptions are annoying, but almost pleasurable, since the teacher has an opportunity to crack a crotchety one-liner and everyone with their cellphone on silent may gloat. (Setting it to vibrate does not count, since the grinding moan of a vibrating phone is equally distracting.)
But I am sitting in a very cold, silent room with about a dozen other dissertating grad students. We’re thinking, reading, writing and we’ve been here for two hours without saying a word to one another. We are focused. And yet already, three different cell phones have begun their equally mortifying ringtones and have been allowed to “ring” until finished. Why? How could anyone think that was appropriate? Would you whistle while you work in a study zone? Would you begin reciting the Declaration of Independance while you and everyone else is attempting intellectually industry? You wouldn’t… or you shouldn’t… and I can’t understand why the owners of these phones don’t scramble for them and turn off their offensive noise. It’s like… aural littering. I want to sit on this bench, but there is gum on it.
So since I haven’t repurposed the shattered pieces of my attention span, I’m complaining about it. Feel free to commiserate with my grumpiness (has anyone noticed that folks on the bus seem to let their ringtones play on purpose before answering, like they are treating us all to a little bit of Top 40 airplay?) or to talk about how your own ringtone is so much better than anyone else’s.



I agree about vibrate! It happens once per crazy final exam I take. (Keep in mind my grade on said exam is my grade for the entire class!) I hear it vibrate, and then I have to question what I am hearing and what in the hell is going on. It completely takes me out of the zone.
People on the subway also like to let us hear their ring tone, and use their iphone speakerphone to play the internal ipod. It is annoying and borderline ear-rape.
As for your bizarre situation with students not scrambling to pick up the phone disrupting the zen silence of dissertation stuff…I’m at a total loss. Perhaps they don’t want to own up to it?
Pick up the ringing phone and helpfully toss it to the owner. Miss. Most phones will lose their batteries upon impact with the floor, problem solved, hint delivered.
I don’t know that I’d go quite so far as damaging the phone, but I do think that I’d take the time to track it down and politely ask the owner to correct their behavior. You were already interrupted anyway, as was everyone else, so why not?